Damn Delicious

Sheet Pan Garlic Butter Mushrooms

The BEST side dish ever! Simply roast your mushrooms in the most heavenly garlic butter sauce on ONE SINGLE PAN!

Sheet Pan Garlic Butter Mushrooms - The BEST side dish ever! Simply roast your mushrooms in the most heavenly garlic butter sauce on ONE SINGLE PAN!

I think you guys may be catching on.

But I’m trying to hit all my recipes on a sheet pan now.

Because at the end of a shoot day, there’s only so many dishes I really feel like doing.

Plus, we had a backed up pipe.

And no water for several hours.

But that was after the mushrooms were tossed on the sheet pan.

So in an effort to save on water and dishwashing, we took out our forks and ate it straight off the pan.

But we couldn’t spare the spoons.

Because we really needed to spoon on some more of that garlic butter sauce.

Sheet Pan Garlic Butter Mushrooms

The BEST side dish ever! Simply roast your mushrooms in the most heavenly garlic butter sauce on ONE SINGLE PAN!

15 minutes15 minutes

Ingredients:

  • 1/4 cup unsalted butter, melted
  • 4 cloves garlic, minced
  • 1 tablespoon freshly squeezed lemon juice, optional
  • 1 teaspoon dried thyme
  • 1/2 teaspoon dried rosemary
  • Kosher salt and freshly ground black pepper, to taste
  • 3 pounds cremini mushrooms

Directions:

  1. Preheat oven to 375 degrees F. Lightly oil a baking sheet or coat with nonstick spray.
  2. In a small bowl, whisk together butter, garlic, lemon juice, thyme and rosemary; season with salt and pepper, to taste.
  3. Place mushrooms in a single layer onto the prepared baking sheet. Stir in butter mixture and gently toss to combine.
  4. Place into oven and bake for 12-15 minutes, or until browned and tender, tossing occasionally.
  5. Serve immediately.

Did you Make This Recipe?

Tag @damn_delicious on Instagram and hashtag it #damndelicious.

Leave a Review

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

49 comments

  1. Rated 5 out of 5

    Delicious!  Do these freeze well?

  2. Being in the middle of a pandemic – I only have salted butter and dried thyme. I do have olive oil. Can I still make these? Or will the salted butter draw to much water out of the mushrooms.? 

  3. Rated 5 out of 5

    I’m giving this 5 stars simply bc I’m sure this is a great recipe but I must have done something wrong! my mushrooms came out very bland w/ no flavor & I followed to a T.  Also, I noticed that my mushrooms released a lot of water & it made them watery.  Any ideas on how to prevent that? Thanks for the recipe! I will try again in the near future! 

  4. Rated 5 out of 5

    Silly question about the spices, but is it ground thyme and rosemary or the actual herb leaves?

  5. Rated 4 out of 5

    Haven’t made it yet but it looks fantastic. My question is would you recommend adding slivered onions.

  6. Rated 5 out of 5

    My hubby loves mushrooms but not one of my favorites but these were so good! The next time we make these I will wrap everything in heavy duty aluminum foil and put them on the grill. Easy and delicious definitely a keeper!

  7. Rated 5 out of 5

    So i rarely come across a mushroom I don’t like, but these are are really good, I like that they are prepared whole, and super easy.

  8. Rated 5 out of 5

    Delicious delicious 

  9. Tasty but not enough butter sauce. 375 wasn’t high enough temp to roast. 400 or even higher would work. Lower temp simply slowly dried mushrooms out and certainly didn’t give mushrooms that lovely look the photos showed because of it….not even close.

    Sooo- Higher temp, more butter sauce to coat and baste mushrooms regularly. Works with any meat or vegetarian meal. What’s not to like about roasted mushrooms. They are the meat of the vegetable world.

  10. What do you do with the juice from the mushrooms that comes out during cooking? I feel like it made the buttery deliciousness a little watery, but I don’t know how to separate it!

  11. OMGOSH!!!! SO GOOOOOD! SUPER EASY! MY FAMILY LOVED IT! DEFINITELY DOING THIS WEEKLY THANK YOU COUE POSTING THIS…LOOKJNG FORWARD TO MORE RECIPES

  12. I don’t like mushrooms—that is, I didn’t THINK I liked mushrooms until today.  TO DIE FOR!  We ate them off of the sheet pan.  Thanks for a terrific recipe that will not be included in the regular rotation!

  13. Is this suitable for meal prep? I always make “dinner for lunch” on workdays, since I start early and skip actual dinner so I can sleep properly, and I’d love to use this recipe for that in some way.
    Thanks in advance!

  14. love you sheet pan recipes. I have tried one and will try the mushroom one for sure… Thanks

  15. The picture looks like it has fresh herbs on the mushrooms but yet the recipe calls for dried thyme and rosemary.  Was there a fresh herb used for the picture?

  16. I would line the pan with foil easier cleanup!

    • research suggests that aluminium foil should not be used for cooking. … It’s safe to wrap cold food in foil, though not for long stretches of time because food has a shelf life and because aluminium in the foil will begin to leach into the food

    • I agree with Robin. Parchament paper is what professional kitchens use, and it can be found in the same section as foil at the grocery store (it is NOT the same as waxed paper or butcher paper – those don’t work in the oven). Parchament paper keeps the heat more even (doesn’t reflect like foil), is better for the environment, and doesn’t tear like foil, so it’s easier to scrape tasty brown bits into the mushroom dish! I use it as a foil replacement when baking/roasting anything!

  17. yep, this works and why not? Much easier than in a saucepan, nice application of sheet panning! Thank you!

  18. I love mushroom. So delicious!

  19. My family, (less son) love, love mushrooms, and we will be making them this weekend.

  20. Sounds and looks delish. But can I use plain old white mushrooms in place of cremini?

  21. I don’t like mushrooms yet you still manage to make me hungry! (:

  22. I can’t have dairy – do you think olive oil would be an ok sub?

    • Unfortunately, without further recipe testing, I cannot answer with certainty. As always, please use your best judgment regarding substitutions and modifications.

    • Olive oil would be fine and it would also keep from burning if you decided to cook with a higher temp. You don’t want to cook at too high of a temp or the garlic will burn, just FYI.

  23. I’m just crazy about fresh thyme and for my birthday, I just received a huge planter full of almost every fresh herb imaginable! This will be the first dish I use my bd present for! Thanks Double D!

  24. Sounds yummy I love mushrooms, going to knock this one out tonight. Great Share Thanks!

  25. Love this Awesome recipe. Never tried this before. Can’t wait to make a try . 🙂

  26. Love your mushrooms, so easy to prepare & so very delicious to eat. Enjoy your rescipies.

  27. Love these. Use sliced mushrooms and top your grilled hamburgers or grilled flank or skirt steak!! Why stop there? Chop the sliced mushrooms and put under skin of a turkey breast or whole chicken. Since this is ‘National Grilling Month’ I will try on the flank steak and whole chicken this weekend since that is our menu for arriving out of town guests. Will let you know!!!!!

  28. This sounds fantastic! I think they would be great with a good steak and some mashed potatoes. 

  29. I love mushrooms! Can’t wait to try these. They look delicious.

  30. When using sheet pans to cook I always use a teflon mat. They’re cheap and easy to clean. Get one intended for a BBQ and they’ll last for years. Also, great thing to put at the bottom of your oven. Gotta try this one out tonight!

  31. Can’t wait to try it

  32. I have some fresh Shiitake mushrooms. Do you think the yummy garlic butter will work with the Shiitake as well? And how much longer do you think they would need to cook? Thanks

    • Unfortunately, without further recipe testing, I cannot answer with certainty. As always, please use your best judgment regarding substitutions and modifications.

  33. Yummy! What do you suggest pairing this with? Thanks!

  34. I am a huge fan of butter mix with mushrooms that was new i will try some day thanks

  35. I just love mushroom and its dished. It was really yummy and delicious.